Markets
Macro

The Fed's Minutes Said More Hikes. The Two-Year Fell 25 Basis Points Anyway.

The Fed's October minutes pointed to further hikes. In the same week the 2-year Treasury yield fell 25 basis points, and the Fed meets December 8-9 with no new CPI in hand.

A neoclassical central bank building at dusk seen across an empty granite plaza

The Federal Reserve's most recent minutes said one thing. The Treasury market did another. Minutes of the October 27-28 meeting, released Wednesday, showed that almost all participants judged that further action to raise the target range for the federal funds rate would likely be appropriate under their baseline outlooks. A couple of participants went further, noting that an increase of more than 25 basis points could warrant consideration if incoming inflation data were unfavorable.

Yet in the same week the front end of the curve rallied hard. The 2-year yield fell from 4.88% on November 13 to 4.63% by Friday, a drop of 25 basis points, while the 10-year fell 23 basis points to 4.92%, according to official data. Investors concluded that December, when the committee meets on the 8th and 9th, brings the last increase of this cycle. That conclusion is now load bearing for equity valuations, and it rests on a calendar that offers the Fed no new inflation reading before it votes.

A committee that wanted to move and did not

The minutes describe a room closer to hiking than the decision suggests. On October 28 the FOMC voted 10-2 to hold the target range at 3.75% to 4%, with Governor Lisa D. Cook and Cleveland Fed President Beth M. Hammack dissenting in favor of a quarter-point increase. The September 16 decision to lift the range by a quarter point to 3.75% to 4% had passed 12-0 by comparison.

That hold came against staff estimates of 12-month total PCE inflation at 3.6% in September and core PCE at 3.1%, driven largely by earlier tariff increases, higher energy prices, and upward pressure on consumer goods prices tied to the AI buildout. Unemployment sat at 4.2%, with payroll gains averaging about 50,000 a month over the three months ending in September. Some participants wanted the quarter point in October itself, and a few warned that further delay risked entrenching high inflation or forcing a larger tightening later.

Waller's condition was already met

The consumer price data published since then gave the dissenters their evidence. October CPI, released November 10, showed all items rising 0.4% after 0.6% in September, while the index for all items less food and energy rose 0.3% for a third straight month. Energy rose 0.7% after a 5.2% September surge, and gasoline was up 37.4% over the 12 months ended October. The Bureau of Labor Statistics could not publish a 12-month all-items change at all, because October 2025 survey data were never collected during a lapse in appropriations, per the release.

Governor Christopher Waller had already drawn the line. In a November 10 speech he put PCE inflation at 0.5% for September and 3.7% over the prior 12 months, with core PCE at 0.3% and 3.1%, and noted that more than 70% of the components of core PCE service prices had 12-month increases above 3%. He said he was leaning toward a quarter point in December, but that if October core came in around 0.3% or higher, a 50 basis point increase should be considered. October core printed exactly 0.3%.

The bet the stock market is leaning on

A 25 basis point drop in the 2-year, paired with 27 basis points in the 5-year, reads as a market pricing the cycle's end rather than a slower pace. The 10-year at 4.92% sits almost exactly where it closed on October 30, at 4.94%, so most of the week's rally was a repricing of policy expectations rather than of the long-run inflation outlook.

Equities spent the week testing whether that assumption survives. By Friday the S&P 500 and the Dow Jones Industrial Average had closed in correction territory, more than 10% below their records, while the Nasdaq Composite lost 10% on the week, its worst since March 2020, and turned negative for the year. The Fed's own financial conditions review had already flagged spreads on speculative-grade bonds widening notably, reflecting the elevated rate sensitivity of riskier firms, and bank equities falling sharply on concerns about slower loan growth and commercial real estate exposures.

No new inflation number before the vote

The awkward part is timing. November CPI is scheduled for Thursday, December 10, two days after the FOMC concludes, with the November jobs report arriving December 4, according to the schedule. The committee decides whether to accelerate with no fresh read on consumer prices since the October print that tripped Waller's threshold, and with only a labor report in hand.

So the rally at the front end rests on an inference rather than a data point. Officials wrote that further increases would likely be appropriate. The market decided December is the last of them. Between those statements sit three consecutive 0.3% core prints, gasoline up 37.4% year over year, and a committee that split 10-2 while inflation ran at 3.1%. If the Fed takes Waller at his word, those 25 basis points were priced against the wrong end of the cycle. If it does not, the equity correction was the detour. The market has picked a side before the Fed has spoken.